| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • Stop wasting time looking for files and revisions. Connect your Gmail, DriveDropbox, and Slack accounts and in less than 2 minutes, Dokkio will automatically organize all your file attachments. Learn more and claim your free account.

View
 

Film Analysis vs Review

Page history last edited by Brad F 6 years ago

 

Sometimes, when we want to know what a movie is about, at the simplest level, we might be asking simply for what happens. In that case, we are asking for a film synopsis:

 

FILM SYNOPSIS:

  • "Recounting the plot of a movie, telling what happens"  
  • A basic summary of a movie that includes key plot developments
    • typically a synopsis avoids mentioning the film's conclusion or any details that would spoil the film's ending, intended surprises, or plot twists
    • this is why we sometimes see the phrase "SPOILER WARNING" 

 

 

but sometimes we are interested in what a movie is about, the meaning of a film, at a more complex or deeper level. In those cases, we write or look for TWO different kinds of written responses to movies:

 

 

FILM REVIEW (or film criticism):

  • "A review... typically includes personal impressions and evaluations of a movie's content and techniques. A good review may touch superficially on topics that might be explored in greater detail in a formal analysis."
  • Film reviews often help readers to decide whether or not to see a film by arguing for its achievements and/or shortcomings.  
    • In this sense, it offers a basic evaluation argument: this is a good (or bad) movie, and provides justification (rationale).
  • Typically published in mass-media outlets (newspapers, tv shows, magazines) for a broad, general audience
  • Typically about 3-4pages 

 

 

...film reviews, while incredibly useful and important arguments, have a different purpose and different genre expectations than the film analysis. Let's take a look:

 

FILM ANALYSIS (or film theory):

  • "An analysis attempts to determine how the film uses various cinematic techniques and elements of narrative form to make a viewer react in a certain way"
  • Film analysis considers the ways that a film might intentionally or unintentionally confirm, alter, or challenge (subvert) cultural norms, ideas, and meaning. It attempts to understand how films participate in social meaning making, and is less concerned with evaluations about whether the film is "good or bad" in a traditional sense. 
  • Typically published in academic journals/essays, or in smaller magazines/blogs, for a specialized audience. 
  • Typically between 7 - 15 pages. 

 

 

 

*The quoted definitions above are borrowed from this Intro to Film Theory by Christopher Jacobs, here

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.